Join Our Team as an Order Fulfillment Specialist at Butter Maid Bakery!

Looking for a fulfilling job with a family-owned business that values its employees? Butter Maid Bakery, located in Youngstown, OH, is searching for enthusiastic individuals to join our team as Order Fulfillment Specialists. We’re proud to be the world’s largest producer of authentic handmade kolachi, and we’re inviting you to be part of the magic!

At Butter Maid Bakery, we’re more than just a workplace—we’re a family. With no seasonal layoffs, no post-holiday job cuts, and a commitment to creating a positive work environment, you’ll find job security and a team that truly cares. Plus, with Monday-Friday daytime hours, you’ll get your life back—no nights, weekends, or graveyard shifts!

What You'll Do

As an Order Fulfillment Specialist, you’ll play a key role in ensuring our delicious baked goods make it to our customers’ doors with care and quality. This is not your average packing or shipping position—our high-volume food manufacturing facility requires attention to detail, teamwork, and a love for learning. Your responsibilities will include:

Packaging and shipping orders with precision.
Baking our signature products.
Maintaining a clean and safe work environment.
Assisting customers when needed.
Operating commercial ovens and working with dough.
Moving between departments to learn and adapt to seasonal needs.

What We're Looking For

We’re seeking individuals who are organized, detail-oriented, and ready to work in a fast-paced environment. Here’s what you’ll need to succeed:

Must be over the age of 18.
Ability to follow instructions and be trainable.
Strong attention to detail and organizational skills.
Ability to read small print for product flavors and quantities.
Physical ability to lift and carry up to 50+ pounds, work on your feet for extended periods, and handle the demands of working with dough.
Willingness to meet food safety dress code requirements (no piercings, jewelry, false nails, nail polish, or false lashes).
Ability to work in and out of a freezer as needed.
Excellent communication and multitasking skills.

Why You'll Love Working Here

At Butter Maid Bakery, we don’t just bake—we make a difference. Here’s what you can look forward to:

Daytime weekday hours (Full-Time: 7 AM–3 PM or 8 AM–4 PM; Part-Time may be available).
Job security—we’re a fast-growing company with no seasonal layoffs or post-holiday job cuts.
Opportunities for growth—earn up to $16+/hr as you grow with us.
Overtime opportunities for those who want to go the extra mile.
Holidays off, including Christmas, New Year’s, Thanksgiving, Easter, Memorial Day, Independence Day, and Labor Day.
Be part of a team that supports U.S. soldiers overseas with cookies and gives back to local food banks.

Ready to Join the Butter Maid Bakery Family?

If you’re a happy, hardworking individual who thrives in a team environment, we’d love to meet you! Apply today and take the first step toward a rewarding career with Butter Maid Bakery. Together, we’ll continue to put Youngstown on the map with our authentic handmade kolachi and exceptional service.

By applying to this job, you agree to receive periodic text messages from this employer and Homebase about your pending job application. Opt out anytime. Msg & data rates may apply.

Powered by Homebase. Free employee scheduling, time clock and hiring tools.